12 hole golf courses

Jack Nicklaus and others are pressing for 12-hole golf courses as a way to engage more beginner golfers and those pressed for time. Please respond with the answer that best matches your opinion.
 

Login Form



Golf Community Reviews
Weird and wonderful: Austin wrap up

dsc_0138riverplacefedextruck.jpg

At River Place, fairways look either up at or down to the surrounding houses.


    Here are some observations about Austin, Texas and its golf communities after my weeklong visit:
    Topographically, the Texas Hill Country is reminiscent of San Francisco, with some of the hills looking more like small mountains.  Every golf course I played was surrounded by the hills, most with homes perched along the ridgelines.  House styles are mostly a meld of Southwestern and Mediterranean, but Tuscan is coming on strong in many of the communities.  Stucco appears to be the dominant housing material  Home prices, even for those with the nice views, tend to be 10% to 20% less than similarly situated homes in places like Asheville, NC (and Austin's summers tend to be 20 degrees hotter on average).  Fair warning:  Texas has no income tax and generates much of its revenue from property taxes, which are considerably higher than many other areas (count on an average of $15,000 in taxes for property valued at $500,000).  Yet Austin is still enough of a bargain in terms of real estate that retired Californians and Floridians are moving there in significant numbers.  I saw houses going up in every community I visited.
    Like most university towns, this one home to the huge University of Texas, there is plenty to do in Austin; as I was leaving town, the annual music festival, Austin City Limits, was starting, with Bob Dylan and other more modern acts featured on numerous stages around town for 12 hours a day the entire weekend.  The comparison to San Francisco goes beyond similarities in topography; the rallying cry in town is "Keep Austin Weird," a slap at the pretensions of the newly wealthy citizens in the high tech industry.  Dell Computer, for example, is headquartered in Round Rock, just north of town; there is concern that some of the city's notorious funkiness may be at risk.  In recent years, two new magazines devoted to the cocktail party and black tie set have been introduced.  They won't be wearing black tie at the area's many barbecue joints where the smoked brisket reigns supreme.
    The five courses I played were good to outstanding.  Falconhead is one of only three "signature" courses in the nation designed by PGA Tour hired architects, something that probably seemed like a good idea at the time.  Falconhead was for the most part a pleasant routing well out in the country; a family of deer watched me play one hole.  The course layout had some flourishes I found excess baggage, such as rectangular sanddsc_0057averyranchrectbunker.jpg bunkers plopped down in the middle of other bunkers, but I generally liked the way the fairways bent around mesquite trees.  Falconhead, which is negotiating with the PGA Tour to sever connections so it can control its own destiny, is going to have to find a way to invest more money in their facilities.  For a daily fee course, lockers are not a necessity, but clean bathrooms are.  That said, the folks in the pro shop and snack bar were among the friendliest I have ever met in a clubhouse.
    Avery Ranch, another daily fee course, was a beehive of activity, with numerous homes under construction around the course.  After awhile, the sound of hammering was as natural as bird chirping.  Although the heavy rains of the night before had left casual water in the bunkers, the fairways and greens had drained well.  Tee placement was especially important on the front nine, with mesquite trees at the edges of fairways to block approach shots to the well-protected greens.  Avery is a course where length is not as important as accuracy. I found the heavy iron fences behind virtually all the houses on the course unnecessary; the homes weren't close to the field of play.
    The University of Texas Golf Club in the huge (6,500-acre) Steiner Ranch community was a terrific surprise for me, the first Bechtol Russell designed course I've played.  The elevation changes seemed entirely natural and forced a few changes of clubs in the fairway to ensure appraoch shots did not roll back down hills in front of the green.  Virtually all the par 4s and 5s are doglegs of some stripe or the other, making it important to dsc_0297utgchornsholemarker.jpg"shape" your shots if you want to shorten the approaches to the greens.  Conditions were superb, as was the professionalism of all staff I met.  The club's Golf Academy has all the latest high-tech software, including two cameras that check your putting stroke. I was impressed by the three "indoor" hitting bays with large doors that opened out onto the driving range. Members and the UT golf teams are pampered at the UT Golf Club.  
    River Place was odyssey golf, which is to say occasionally weird and occasionally wonderful.  For a first timer, the course was quite difficult, posing too many blind tee shots and blind approaches.  One par 5 was horribly designed, with a big hill running down from lay-up range to a pond in front of the green.  People I met in the days before sniffed about the River Place layout, but despite the par 5 and a few balls I lost "in plain sight," I would like to give River Place another shot someday.  It was in superb condition, the hills around the course were the most dramatic of the week and, unlike at the other communities, the vistas were not burdened by high-tension wires.  The surrounding community, with most houses perched on ridgelines, was also the most attractive of the week.
    At The Hills Country Club at Lakeway, about 35 minutes from Austin, you can belong to two private courses, two daily fee courses or to all four of them.  I played the private Hills course, an early Jack Nicklaus design (1981) that shows the Bear's raw talents.  The trees in the fairway and his bias toward high left to right shots is in evidence at the Hills, but Nicklaus showed considerable overall restraint in embedding the course in the gently rolling hills near Lake Travis.  The routing was easier on the eyes than it was on my golf clubs, but it was not as relentlessly tough on mid handicappers as some Nicklaus courses of the ‘80s tend to be.  The Hills hosts the annual FedEx/Kinko's event on the Champions Tour, and it was almost in tournament shape in September, beautifully landscaped with greens that, although top-dressed with sand and aerated a week earlier, were near flawless.
    None of the golf carts I used during the week had protective covers for your golf clubs, even those at the private, higher end country clubs.  I know it rains in Austin but maybe never on a golf course.  And for a large state that is known to do everything big, I will never get used to the size of the housing lots in Texas cities.  Even 3,000+ square foot houses are within just 20 feet of their neighbors' houses.  One acre lots and higher are few and far between.  Those used to lots of space might feel claustrophic in an Austin golf community.          One last note:  In six days, I saw two cowboy hats, one in a coffee shop and one at the airport as I was leaving town.  How weird is that?
    I'll report at greater length on the golf and the real estate in the Austin area in an upcoming issue of HomeOnTheCourse.

 

dsc_0250utgc18thhole.jpg

The 18th at University of Texas Golf Club is backed by the soon to open $16 million clubhouse.

[where:  78705] 

Sunday, 16 September 2007 02:28
 
Dye for a dollar is big deal

dsc_0004wintonbury2ndholeteebox.jpg
 Anyplace but high on the fairway right provides a challenging approach shot to the firm 2nd green at Bloomfield, CT's Wintonbury Hills Golf Club.

 

    Five years ago, Pete Dye donated his design services for the town of Bloomfield, CT's Wintonbury Hills golf course for $1, or an estimated three million less than Tiger will get for his first American design for The Cliffs Communities.  Bloomfield got a great deal.
    Yesterday I played Wintonbury Hills, which is located about eight miles northwest of Hartford, with Ken, Joe and Bernie.  Ken is a HomeOnTheCourse Community Guide subscriber and Joe and Bernie were taking a day off from their management positions at the local Coca Cola Bottling office.  They chose a great, sunny day, with temperatures in the high 60s (F) and the course in very nice shape.  I have played Wintonbury a number of times, and I expected the fairways and greens to be extremely firm, forcing many bump and run shots to greens with pin positions at front.  The course ran true to form yesterday.  Shots at the pin just would not hold, and 20 foot putts or chips through fringe were preferable to 40 foot putts from the back of Dye's undulating greens (Tim Liddy, gets co-design credit on the scorecard).
    Ken was right on when he described Wintonbury as a course that "looks like parkland but plays like links."
    Indeed, from the clubhouse, the views are wide open to fairways and large greens in the distance, and it does affect a links land feel.  But once you reach the edges of the course, the holes thread through trees and around a few ponds and marshland hazards. 

The course features 125 bunkers and firm, medium fast greens.

The course is not long, measuring less than 6,700 yards from the tips and less than 6,300 from the tees we played, but when the wind blows, as it did yesterday, the course's genial ratings and slopes can seem a tad conservative, especially with pins just behind a number of false fronts.  Although few of the 125 bunkers are in play for the better golfer off the tee, those around the green are well placed and built into hillsides.  With its firm footing and small, angled bunkers, Wintonbury is not a bad tuneup for a trip to the Old Sod.
    The course is not without its quirks, which keep it from rating an overall otustanding (I rate the course a 7 on a scale of 1 to 10).  Among the idiosyncrasies are two sets of holes - 1 and 10, and 2 and 11 - that are nearly identical in design.  The opener is a straight on par four, with hazard stakes fronting the marsh well to the left and bunkers guarding the slightly elevated green.  Ditto number 10.  The second is an uphill dogleg left, with most of the trouble on the left in the form of rough and trees before an uphill approach to another well guarded elevated green.  Number 11, which takes an identical routing up and left, adds a few pot bunkers at the crook of the dogleg and some bailout fairway to the left of the bunkers.  The better approach to the green is from top right since the green is blind from the fairway on the left.
    The routine par 4 16th, which plays downhill to the green, seems self consciously "tricked up," as if the designers couldn't avoid making it short but wanted to make it much more difficult.  The huge mound guarding the front left half of the green is too close to the putting surface; with the pin just over it, as it was yesterday, there was no way for even a well-played short-iron shot from the center to the left side of the fairway to be rewarded with less than a 15 foot putt.
    For those who need the practice range before a round of golf, Wintonbury Hills' is up the road, a little too far for a cart ride.  Compensation is in the practice green complex just behind the clubhouse, which includes a few sand traps as well as an undulating surface that previews the greens on the course.  Wintonbury also permits chipping to the practice green.
    Despite the firm playing conditions, the turf was in nice shape for mid-fall, and clearly the grounds crew had preceded us with their leaf blowers and collectors.  We never came close to losing a ball in the leaves, not the case at many tree-lined courses in Connecticut.  Greens were not as fast as usual - they had not been cut that morning - but you still needed to be careful from above the hole (I'd estimate the stimpmeter reading at about 9).  A well-struck wedge shot typically bounded six to 10 feet beyond the slight dent it made in the putting surfaces.
    Because of Dye's involvement and positive national publicity in the golfing mags, managers flying into the nearby Bradley Airport for corporate meetings in Hartford have been making detours to Wintonbury for a round of golf before their business discussions.  In the summer, tee times are necessary, but the Wintonbury web site makes it quite easy to book a time in advance (or you can call the pro-shop).
    Wintonbury's clubhouse is small, but the pro shop is well stocked and the restaurant is first-class for a municipal/daily fee club, serving not only the excellent snack foods (hamburgers, hot dogs) you expect but also including some daily specials.  Green fees, with cart (GPS included), were just $60.  Memberships are available to town residents and non-residents alike, with annual dues (no initiation fees) beginning around $2,000 for residents for a weekday pass (unlimited play Monday thru Friday).  For a course of this quality, that is a bargain, almost as good a deal as getting Pete Dye to design the track for a buck.
    Wintonbury Hills Golf Club, 206 Terry Plains Road, Bloomfield, CT.  (860) 242-1401.  Web:  www.wintonburyhillsgolf.com.  Tournament tees: 6,623 yards, rating 72.3, slope 130.  Back tees: 6,283 yards, rating 70.0, slope 128.

 

dsc_0038wintonburythreeguys.jpg

Left to right, Ken, Joe and Bernie were great company at Wintonbury Hills. 

Thursday, 18 October 2007 04:31
 
Sweet Home Alabama: Big discounts for Jones Trail Card holders

oxmoorvalley12splitfairwayleft.jpg

The Oxmoor Valley course on the Robert Trent Jones Trail is one of the few with some housing within view of the course.  Above is the unique par 4 12th hole with a double fairway separated by a large grove of trees (to the right here).  The left fairway is tougher to hit off the tee, but the easier approach to the protected green.


    As the flagsticks go into the cups north of the Mason-Dixon line, golfers in the southern U.S. are already warmed up for the season.  Most golf courses in the Carolinas on down have been open all winter except for a few frigid and snowy days.  Southern golfers' idea of the new playing season is for the dormant grasses in the rough to go from brown to green.  That is starting to happen everywhere.
    This is also the season, especially in this economy, when affiliated golf courses offer their discount cards or "passports," which offer low-priced green fees and discounts on merchandise and, in some cases, restaurant meals.  No discount program I know of is a better deal than the Robert Trent Jones Trail Card because no affiliated group of courses is consistently better, in my experience.
    The card costs a mere $39 annually for residents of Alabama or anyone who lives within 100 miles of a Jones Trail course.  By my calculation, that brings some border towns in Georgia and Tennessee into play.
    Lucky them.   With the Card, discounts range from just $34.95 at Silver Lakes near Anniston (played it, liked it) to $39.95 at Grand National in Opelika (liked it) to $44.95 at Oxmoor Valley in Birmingham (loved it) to the $79.95 at the tournament tested Ross Bridge, also in Birmingham (didn't play).  Rates include a golf cart which, at many high-end public courses, can run as high as $30 alone.  During the summer, rates for those without the Card run from $62 to $136 for the same courses.
    There are very few homes adjacent to the Jones Trail courses, but here are a few listings I found.  Of course, there is a wide selection of homes within a mile or two of almost all 26 courses on the trail:

Grand National Golf Club, Opelika, AL

5 BR, 4 ½ BA two-year old home with 3-car garage and deck overlooking course
$545,900

Oxmoor Valley Golf Club, Birmingham, AL
The Cornerstones, 2 & 3 BR condominiums, 1,700 square feet and up, overlooking 17th fairway
Prices begin at $220,000

Lakewood Golf Club, Point Clear, AL
The Commons condominiums, 2 & 3 BR condos, 1,350 square feet and up, near Mobile Bay.
Prices begin at $425,000

Tuesday, 07 April 2009 15:46
 
Is foul odor of market slowdown hanging over Tennessee National?

    I wrote here last Saturday about properties at Tennessee National, the Greg Norman golf community near Knoxville and about what seemed like a reasonably priced Discovery Package.  Emails to two of the marketing and

A slow market and local mushroom farm are stinking things up for Tennessee National.

sales associates at Tennessee National have gone unanswered; I wanted to know simply if the $149 two-day/one-night Discovery Package included a round of golf on the excellent Norman course.  I figured the lack of a response might signal that sales traffic was brisk and the sales associates were just too busy to respond within a week.
    Not so, according to one of our readers, after she read my article, and to a group of folks who live in the Knoxville area.
    "They have stopped all plans for amenities until the market has improved," wrote our reader, who was happy to be able to sell a piece of investment property at Tennessee National a few months ago.  "They are located near a mushroom farm which exudes a bad odor now and...Greg Norman [may have] ditched this project."
    I trust the opinion of our readers but I wanted to do a little further independent digging.  I posted a query at the Knoxville forum of City-Data.com, a web site that can be helpful in terms of local knowledge around the nation if you take what is said with a grain of salt.  Some people have axes to grind with a particular community, but I found these responses to my question quite balanced.
    "Promises were made to build a marina, golf pro shop, and club," wrote someone with the screen name OldManBob, who indicated he is not a resident of Tennessee National, "[but] nothing yet, and many lots are not selling."
    "Too large, too extravagant, overshot their budget on infrastructure
Builders were obligated to buy multiple lots and build spec homes, which now are sitting unsold.

up-front costs, now they don't have money to build their 'promised' amenities," wrote another local, "because the lots aren't moving and they don't have capital."  However, the same writer added, "It can be a gorgeous development" and they have started to "cut the road down to the boat dock and marina."  However, the writer adds, no construction equipment is present at the marina site.
    "One problem Tennessee National has," according to another City-Data contributor, "is that builders were obligated to buy multiple lots and build spec houses.  Neither the houses or (sic) lots have sold and since most are small builders, they are facing a real cash crunch.  I look for there to be some who just walk away, and there will be a bunch of lots (and spec houses as well) going into forclosure (sic)."
    A resident of the nearby sprawling (5,000 acre) community known as Tellico Village (with three 18-hole golf courses), named for the huge lake that was created by the Tennessee Valley Authority controlled flooding 40 years ago, echoed a cautionary note about amenities that you will find me harping about often in this space.
    "...we are pretty much sold on Tellico Village, if you want a golf/lake community," he wrote. "We know that these sort of things [unfilled promises] happen with planned developments when the economy changes.  At TV [Tellico Village], all the amenities are in place and the development and its association are mature and operating in the black for years.
    "They continue to upgrade and expand facilities," he added, "as the community grows, so it doesn't look old or raggedy.  And I think you get more for your money when you buy a resale home."
    "You don't get to custom design it, but I can live with that."
    Wisdom from the front lines of home ownership.

 

If you would like to read the full discussion at City-Data, click here.

Friday, 14 November 2008 08:53
 
Mt. Anthony club well decorated
         Some golf clubs -- and their members -- are content with a well-kept golf course, a decent clubhouse and restaurant, and a friendly efficient staff.  In my experience, most do just that.  If they don't, especially in this environment, their customers have plenty of other options.

         A few clubs add an extra touch that communicates seriousness of purpose as well as an extra dollop of welcome for members and guests.  I wandered into the Mt. Anthony Golf Club in Bennington, VT, on my way back from a weeklong Vermont trip on Friday.  The staff and owners, the Griffin family, had festooned the area around the clubhouse with the accoutrements of the season. This is the kind of touch that makes strangers who play the course for the first time, or those who just make a brief visit, as I did, want to come back again.

         I will.  The place must look great on July 4th weekend.

mtanthonypumpkins.jpg

Sunday, 04 October 2009 19:39
 
<< Start < Prev 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Next > End >>

Page 12 of 271